Critics’ Corner

HLP Books in Review

Sweet Wolf Selected & New Poems

The stylistic and thematic insights of the New Narrative both “inform” and “are validated” in Robert McDowell’s “superb” Sweet Wolf Selected & New Poems, writes Frederick Pollack in his astute review. “[S]tory itself is the primary metaphor” and also what “involves and creates context” in McDowell’s narrative poems. The former results in work that can be “intense and intimately disturbing,” as in the long poem “The Pact”; the latter, focused on “the middle distance: a town, a neighborhood, the history of a family or group of friends,” reveals McDowell’s awareness and knowledge “of what the powerful are like and what they do to the world,” as in”Red Foxes,” which includes, Pollack notes, McDowell’s “painful description of a farm enclosure.” In his lyric poems, too, Pollack adds, “McDowell’s long training in and continued allegiance to narrative” make for “precise, unsentimental” poems “concerned with the context of subjective experience — with seeing . . . from outside.”

Delineating three stages that Sweet Wolf‘s personae experience, stages the reviewer associates with the “locations of the poet’s adult life” (California, Oregon, and Oregon as “a place in the heart”), Pollack draws from McDowell’s “The Cop from Traffic Accident Control,” “The Liberate Bowler,” “The Ballad of Maritime Mike,” and “The Nineties,” among other poems, to illustrate McDowell’s “overarching concern” with gender roles and his handling of conflict between male and female personae whose own needs and weaknesses and “confusing expectations” of self and others lead to lack of intimacy and compassion, even cruelty. Such themes, Pollack notes, have “the effect . . . of bracing honesty and often considerable humor” and underscore, as in “All I Took with the Sun,” “a yearning for something better — a community in which happiness and reconciliation are possible” along with a sense of achievement. Among other themes that Pollack interrogates are doubt, irony, bitterness, and sharp self-accusation and -examination.

Pollack concludes his review by praising McDowell’s “immensely inventive and varied” work; its “overall tone,” which is “combative, truthful, unsentimental yet anything but ‘cold'”; and “the portrait [of McDowell] that emerges from Sweet Wolf,” which is “that of a man of our times and of a ‘man in full’ — one whose work should be recognized.”

Read the interview in full.

The Excellent Assembly

In his advance-of-publication review on Substack, M. Sarki writes of the “enormous courage” it took HLP publisher and poet Robert McDowell “to write these poems, especially in the voices of those intimately involved with that day. . . I was surprised at how McDowell’s poems moved me and made me relive this day of infamy.”

While acknowledging that he “usually avoid[s] reading works by other poets and writers [with whom] I have even the most casual of relationships,” 9/11’s importance “impelled me to at least have a peek into what McDowell was up to. . . .”

Including in his review two of the collection’s poems “that struck me the hardest” — “Blamer” and “Letter Home” — Sarki concludes that “Robert McDowell, in his own special way, has done his part in raising the dead” and honoring their memory.

Breakwater Rock

Reviewing Bruce Lawder’s collection Breakwater Rock, Glynn Young at Tweetspeak Poetry recounts how the act of remembering a place can stir a sense of loss and dislocation on revisiting it. This, he writes, is what Lawder discovered on a hometown visit: “[t]he place is still there but [. . .] most things have changed; even those that seem the same aren’t quite the way you remember them.” It’s a feeling readers might find familiar, Young suggests, and, citing Lawder’s poem “Lamentation,” come to mourn. “Remembering a place and your childhood with it and mourning the loss of the familiar [are] about understanding and acceptance. As Breakwater Rock so amply shows, you, too, will one day pass, becoming a memory, a family story, a retelling of an old joke, a name and date on a genealogy chart, a fallen leaf carried by the river.”

Destinations

At Tweetspeak Poetry, Glynn Young’s review of Michael Favala Goldman’s ninth collection of poetry, Destinations, highlights the poet’s “unique voice” and “use of simple language [that] creates the sense of statement of fact: this is what it is, and you can mourn or lament but it’s better to accept and move on.” Despite the book’s subjects, which include divorce, physical impairment, romance gone awry, and lost friendship, the poems, Young adds, are “not dark ones.”

Emily & Virginia

Barbara Dana, author of A Voice of Her Own: Becoming Emily Dickinson and Young Joan, calls Robert McDowell’s novel Emily & Virginia an “extraordinary novel” that is “deeply intelligent, devoted, poetic and timeless, a fantasy so real you can taste it. Woven from meticulous research of the mind and heart, this meeting of Emily Dickinson and Virginia Woolf is a gem. McDowell knows these women, two brilliant artists, each “irreverent, a pistol and painfully shy.”

To read Emily & Virginia, says Kristin Czarnecki, formerly an English professor at Georgetown College, Georgetown, Ky., past president of the Virginia Woolf Society, and now executive director of Rockport (Mass.) Art Association & Museum, is to take “a rollicking journey through time and space, exploring literature, art, friendship, and love in smart, sparkling writing.”

Every Possible Thing

The chapbook Every Possible Thing, by Karen Poppy, “invites the reader to choose tenderness, choose nature, and, overall, to choose life,” writes Hannah Rousselot, a queer French-American poet, author, educator, and host of the podcast Poetry Aloud. “The poems, lines, and stanzas are short and sweet, allowing the reader to savor each image. [. . .] It is not a chapbook to be read quickly but rather one that increases in depth the more deliberately you ponder its words. The images are deliciously juxtaposed.[. . .]

The Gift of Not Finding

Confessing that Carol Alena Aronoff is not her “usual go-to” poet, reviewer Devon Balwit admits that “when I slowed down and read the poems with attention, I found them [to be] tidy koans that rewarded contemplation.” Aronoff’s The Gift of Not Finding: Poems for Meditation, Balwit writes, “remind[s] us that there is value in slowing down, in breathing, in allowing.” Having given way to her initial hesitation to “practice” the poems, Balwit ultimately allows “these gentle poems to work and for” her.

A Tale of Two Souls

Republished on Facebook by Highland Park Poetry in 2024, a review by Michael Escoubas, senior editor, contributing poet, and staff book reviewer for Quill and Parchment, describes Shai Har-El’s story-in-verse as “a visual and poetic triumph” by a poet “responding to the constant renewing of life, no matter what life throws in his path.” This “tender” narrative of loss, he writes, “features beautiful photos of nature,” and “weaves a message of love and redemption that will stand the test of time.”

What More Could the Universe Want

In his March 2023 interview with Dennis Sampson, Dan Domench, an American short story writer, playwright, and screenwriter, calls the poet’s ninth collection a “fine book [that] made me jealous of his ability to describe the natural world and consider its mysteries. There are images here made unforgettable by the music of his sentences.”